Paul’s Live From New York Pizza on F Street in Eureka has been bringing New York-style pizza to California’s North Coast since it opened, producing the thin-crust, properly sauced, coal-fired New York pizza that earns a Humboldt County restaurant its regional reputation in a market that had no access to the real thing before Paul arrived. It appeared in Season 19, Episode 2 of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, “All Things NY,” which aired February 14, 2014. Guy Fieri found a Eureka pizza kitchen doing authentic New York-style pizza from scratch with the technique and ingredient sourcing that earns a small Northern California city its most distinctive pizza destination.
Quick Facts
Restaurant: Paul’s Live From New York Pizza
City: Eureka, California
Cuisine: Pizza
DDD Season: 19
DDD Episode: 2
Episode Title: All Things NY
Original Air Date: February 14, 2014
Address: 604 F St., Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: 707-442-5800
Website: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com
Status: Open
What to Eat
The New York-Style Cheese Slice on a properly thin and crispy crust is the benchmark — the slice that tells you whether the pizza kitchen understands what makes a New York pizza different from every other style. Paul’s answer has been yes since it opened. The Pepperoni Slice with proper thin-cupped pepperoni and quality cheese is the other classic most regulars rotate between. The Specialty Whole Pies with creative toppings are the option for groups wanting to go beyond the slice counter classics. Find a Humboldt County hotel on Travelocity.
Plan Your Visit
Check the website for current hours.
Address: 604 F St., Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: 707-442-5800
Website: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com
Status: Open
Triple D Essentials
Stream the All Things NY episode on Amazon.
This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Paul’s Live From New York Pizza appeared in Season 19, Episode 2 of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, “All Things NY,” originally aired February 14, 2014.