Bill Smith started at Mustache Bill’s Diner as a dishwasher at age 14, when it was still called the Barnegat Light Diner. He bought it in 1972 and ran it for over 50 years. He never bought anything pre-made. He cracked whole eggs instead of using liquid egg cartons. He made gravy the old-fashioned way, from pan drippings and stock. He invented the Cyclops — a ring-shaped pancake with an egg in the middle — on the spot one morning when eight simultaneous orders for pancakes and eggs came in and he needed to save griddle space. That kind of ingenuity, repeated daily for five decades, earned Mustache Bill’s a James Beard American Classic Award in 2004 and a spot on Season 2, Episode 13 of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives — “The New Jersey Diner Tour,” aired January 28, 2008. Guy Fieri admired Smith’s commitment to making gravy the way it used to be made. By 2023 Smith was ready to retire, and the diner was listed for sale. As of 2024 it continued operating seasonally.
Quick Facts
Restaurant: Mustache Bill’s Diner
City: Barnegat Light, New Jersey
Cuisine: Breakfast / Diner Fare
DDD Season: 2
DDD Episode: 13
Episode Title: The New Jersey Diner Tour
Original Air Date: January 28, 2008
Address: 704 Broadway (at 8th Ave.), Barnegat Light, NJ 08006
Phone: 609-494-0155
Website: https://mustachebills.com/
Status: Open (Seasonal — Friday through Sunday)
About Mustache Bill’s Diner
The diner opened in 1959 at the northern tip of Long Beach Island, two blocks from the Barnegat Lighthouse. For decades it served the fishing community, summer vacationers, and year-round locals with the same uncompromising scratch-cooking approach that Bill Smith brought to every shift. The 1950s-style diner structure — small, unpretentious, with counter seating and booths — has not changed much in 65 years because it doesn’t need to. The food is what matters, and the James Beard Foundation said so explicitly: “For more than thirty-five years Bill Smith has made everything from scratch, refusing to buy anything pre-made. It’s the homemade, straight-from-the-heart cooking that makes Mustache Bill’s a must-stop destination on the Jersey Shore.”
Important notes for visitors: Mustache Bill’s is cash only. It operates seasonally, open Friday through Sunday from roughly 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM. Call ahead or check the website before making the trip, especially outside peak summer season.
What to Eat at Mustache Bill’s Diner
The Cyclops is the signature — a ring-shaped pancake with a fried egg in the center, invented on the fly and now the dish most visitors order first. Bill Smith’s pancakes are made with fresh batter rather than just-add-water mixes, which produces the fluffy, resilient texture that regulars describe as the real difference. The Raisin Bread French Toast has its own devoted following. The Taylor Porkroll Egg and Cheese is the Jersey Shore classic done properly. The Crabmeat, Mushroom, and Cheese Omelet — not a common diner offering — shows what happens when a scratch kitchen takes liberties with the menu. The Fried Clam Platter is worth knowing about for lunch.
If you want to wake up your own griddle game at home, Guy Fieri’s Flavortown Burger Joint Seasoning brings the diner energy to your backyard, and Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives: An All-American Road Trip with Recipes is the cookbook that captures everything the show celebrates.
Plan Your Visit
Mustache Bill’s is open Friday through Sunday, approximately 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM during the operating season. Cash only. The lighthouse is two blocks away — worth the walk after breakfast.
Address: 704 Broadway, Barnegat Light, NJ 08006
Phone: 609-494-0155
Website: https://mustachebills.com/
Status: Open (Seasonal)
Triple D Essentials
Mustache Bill’s scratch breakfast philosophy is the kind of thing Guy Fieri puts in print — Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives: An All-American Road Trip with Recipes celebrates exactly this approach. Stream the New Jersey Diner Tour episode on Amazon before you make the trip to Long Beach Island.
This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Mustache Bill’s Diner appeared in Season 2, Episode 13 of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, “The New Jersey Diner Tour,” originally aired January 28, 2008. The diner received a James Beard American Classic Award in 2004.