The Faves...

Guy's Top 10 Restaurants and Dishes

Over the years, Guy has uncovered some true gems, with dishes that have left a lasting impression. Here’s a roundup of Guy’s top 10 favorite restaurants from the show, complete with in-depth reviews of the standout dish from each spot, as well as the season and episode where they were featured.

1. The Squeeze Inn

Address: 5301 Power Inn Rd, Sacramento, CA 95820
Season: 4, Episode: 8
Closed: August 2020

Favorite Dish: Squeeze with Cheese
The Squeeze Inn was all about the “Squeeze with Cheese” burger, a juicy patty topped with a massive skirt of crispy, grilled cheese that extended beyond the bun. Guy loved the unique twist this added to the burger, making it one of his all-time favorites. Sadly, the Sacramento location closed in 2020, but its legacy lives on.

2. Louie’s Grill & Bar

Address: 9401 Lake Hefner Pkwy, Oklahoma City, OK 73120
Season: 10, Episode: 12

Favorite Dish: Loaded Queso
Louie’s Grill & Bar is a must-visit in Oklahoma City for its “Loaded Queso,” a hearty dish loaded with seasoned beef, pico de gallo, and jalapeños over a bed of rich, creamy queso. The combination of savory, spicy, and cheesy elements made this one of Guy’s top picks from the show.

3. Southside Soda Shop

Address: 1122 S Main St, Goshen, IN 46526
Season: 2, Episode: 5

Favorite Dish: Philly Chili
At Southside Soda Shop, the “Philly Chili” became an instant favorite for Guy. This dish combines Philly cheesesteak flavors with a spicy, hearty chili, creating a comforting and flavorful meal that is perfect any time of the year.

4. Uncle Louie’s Diner

Address: 2129 E Thompson Blvd, Ventura, CA 93001
Season: 7, Episode: 11

Favorite Dish: Hangover Burger
Uncle Louie’s Diner serves up the “Hangover Burger,” a deliciously messy creation topped with a fried egg, bacon, and cheese. Guy was impressed with how this burger delivered the perfect mix of breakfast and lunch flavors, making it a standout dish on the show.

5. Mama Cozza’s

Address: 2170 W Ball Rd, Anaheim, CA 92804
Season: 1, Episode: 6

Favorite Dish: Sicilian Meatball Sandwich
Mama Cozza’s in Anaheim has been a staple for Italian comfort food, and the “Sicilian Meatball Sandwich” is no exception. This massive sandwich, loaded with a giant meatball, marinara sauce, and melted cheese, left a lasting impression on Guy with its hearty, home-cooked goodness.

6. The Blue Door Pub

Address: 1811 Selby Ave, St Paul, MN 55104
Season: 13, Episode: 11

Favorite Dish: Juicy Blucy
The Blue Door Pub in St. Paul is famous for its “Juicy Blucy,” a twist on the Juicy Lucy burger with blue cheese stuffed inside the patty. Guy couldn’t resist the way the molten blue cheese oozed out with each bite, adding a tangy and creamy kick to the already delicious burger.

7. The Red Arrow Diner

Address: 61 Lowell St, Manchester, NH 03101
Season: 2, Episode: 6

Favorite Dish: American Chop Suey
The “American Chop Suey” at The Red Arrow Diner is a New England classic that Guy couldn’t pass up. This comforting dish, featuring elbow macaroni, ground beef, and tomato sauce, was a nostalgic and hearty meal that hit all the right notes for Guy.

8. The Pit Room

Address: 1201 Richmond Ave, Houston, TX 77006
Season: 26, Episode: 9

Favorite Dish: Brisket
The Pit Room in Houston, Texas, is a barbecue lover’s dream, with their smoked brisket standing out as a fan favorite. Guy was captivated by the brisket’s tender, melt-in-your-mouth texture and its rich, smoky flavor, making it a top pick from the show’s BBQ explorations.

9. Pappy’s Smokehouse

Address: 3106 Olive St, St Louis, MO 63103
Season: 4, Episode: 1

Favorite Dish: Ribs
Pappy’s Smokehouse is a St. Louis institution, known for its Memphis-style ribs. These ribs are smoked for hours until they’re fall-off-the-bone tender and coated in a sweet and tangy sauce. Guy couldn’t get enough of these perfectly cooked ribs, solidifying Pappy’s as one of his top BBQ spots.

10. The Porthole Restaurant & Pub

Address: 20 Custom House Wharf, Portland, ME 04101
Season: 11, Episode: 2

Favorite Dish: Lobster Mac & Cheese
The Porthole Restaurant & Pub in Portland, Maine, serves up the “Lobster Mac & Cheese,” a dish that combines rich, creamy cheese with chunks of fresh lobster. Guy loved the indulgent flavors and the generous portions of lobster, making this a must-try when in Portland.